UK light heavyweight Buatsi made a winning yet underwhelming start to his career under fresh promotional backing with a decision win over Zach Parker in the Manchester arena.
The Olympic bronze medallist's work rate seemingly secured him a split decision in a tight ten-round bout at the Manchester venue.
But Parker landed significant shots, landing some telling individual punches in a fight where the styles didn't complement each other, with frequent clinching spoiling the fight.
The officials had it 96-94 in favor to the winner, with the final judge a even score.
"It wasn't my best showing but how do champions respond? They succeed," the victor commented in the ringside as he was met by negative reactions from the audience.
The British fighter got back to winning after his maiden career setback - an memorable fight with his previous opponent in February - to claim a 20th pro success.
Various analysts thought the challenger, 31, deserved the decision but the contender suffered the second defeat of his 28-bout professional journey.
Buatsi Claims Win in Slow Match
His career development has stalled in recent years through promotional disputes and extended periods of inactivity.
Earlier forecast as the rising talent of the British fight scene, he now stands trying to fulfil that early promise - maybe in what appears to be a last chance - under recent support.
He opened tentatively, with the two boxers ready to take risks in a cagey early stages.
The challenger, whose single earlier setback came at the lower weight class against his former opponent in 2022 after suffering a hand injury during the bout, was making just his second fight at the higher weight class.
By the fight's midpoint, the underdog had stayed in contention, creating difficulties for Buatsi, who utilized a protective stance to barely take the cleaner stanzas.
The crowd's patience wore thin amid constant clinching, with the challenger going down several times during clinches.
The underdog ended stronger, but many rounds were difficult to score. However, ex-champion the boxing analyst - providing analysis for the broadcast network - had it significantly in favor for Parker, awarding Buatsi just only one stanza.
Buatsi moves on, but with the caliber of hard hitter Benavidez, and Eastern European fighter Dmitry Bivol ruling the division, the road to world glory - based on this performance - still looks steep.
Ricky Hatton Homage Inspires Manchester Derby Fight
In the supporting bout, Arthur overcame Bradley Rea by divided decision in a terrific Manchester vs Manchester fight to win the continental title.
The arena grew hushed for a deeply poignant tribute before the fight as ten bells sounded in remembrance of Manchester's own Hatton, who passed away at age 46 in last month.
It was the premier televised fight night in the location since Hatton's death. As the last bell disappeared, the stillness transitioned to a chant of "there's just one Ricky Hatton".
The competition during the bout reflected the feeling. Arthur was knocked down by a powerful punch flush on the chin in the second round, standing uncertainly to his footing on the count of eight.
But the traditional red shorts of Arthur soon advanced again. On the opposite side, the opponent - in rival City blue - was marked up quickly, significant bruising forming under his orbital area as the pair landed hard punches.
Rea, 27, landed power punches but the champion, 34, matched the intensity with powerful upward punches as the pace rarely dropped over the full distance.
The victor edged the verdict with scoring tallies of 114-114, close margin and 115-112, but both fighters were determined and courageous, everything their hero Hatton represented.